« Focus on paragraphs | Main | Toward the article review assignment »

Additional guidance on the review

that restates what we have been talking about in class. What shape is your document now?

Documents  have beginnings, middles, and ends.  For this work, think LEMON-shaped or PEAR-shaped.  

Beginning: 1-3ish paragraphs that prepare the reader to understand and trust the center portion of your analysis (three or four body paragraphs).  Use a cognitive wedge strategy aka "lemon nipple." Think:

  • Opening (see the seven strategies -- you can combine them,
  • Ethos of lead author (some sample language below),
  • Definitions/descriptions or backgrounds, which is largely common knowledge. You can use
    • bullet strategy
    • consider an audience-friendly referral sentence or two (use your words; not a link, as we need to imagine this as a presentation setting and not a hyperlinked document).

Middle: 3-4ish body paragraphs. Start with one paragraph per point BUT you may need to divide complex material into two shorter but connected (by transition) paragraph. These are your larger paragraphs.  You MAY need to nest small definitions -- use the appositive technique -- near the material.

End: In the LEMON-shape, you taper off, with some useful information or thoughts for closing.  For example, brief critique about stats (this is hard and will NOT count against your work grade-wise), applications, further line of inquiry, implications for society. In the PEAR-shape closure, you use several small paragraphs to describe implications of this research.

NEW LINK: Academic language phrase bank (really useful for analysis and writing). Spend some time here AND save the link.   Thank you to the fine folks at Manchester University, UK.

REPOSTING this resource on Opening moves for technical documents: (seven ways! With examples.)

ETHOS para detail: Citation/ethos/introduce your lead researcher:  in class, we will talk about the conventions of citation in a close read of an article.  Basically, the steps are:

  1. first mention, full name (in the ethos paragraph that also introduces the article).
    • (author, date)
  2. last name throughout
  3. Example:  Marybeth Shea is a professor of technical writing at the University of Maryland. She studies stasis theory in environmental policymaking.  Her research article appears in the Journal of Conservation Biology and is the subject of this review (Shea, 2014). Then, in rest of document, refer to the work using the last name:
    • Shea's approach...
    • Her findings...
    • What Shea's inference fails to account for...

Finally, phrases that you can use throughout the document to propel your analysis to the end.

Before we look at Patel's work on food additives, let's review a few key definitions.

You can read more about polyphenols and oxidative stress at the open pages of the Nutrician Society of the US.

Let's turn now to Suarez's use of bioplastics in 3-D printing applications for oyster restoration. First, Suarez describes....

A second key take-away from Cummings' analysis of ankle joint morphology concerns wear and tear on patellar (kneecap) interior surfaces.

The first two points from Mozafari's cardiac perfusion study strongly support her conclusion concerning injectable medications administered in the field, while enroute by ambulance.

Most bioretention specialists will appreciate the specific findings about nitrogen uptake by hedgerows. This knowledge is important for farmers seeking mixed benefits from using plants as flexible "green tech": windbreaks, shade for energy conservation, screening from neighbors, and for sinking nitrogen into the soil, out of the airshed.

See you Friday.  Try to have between 5 and 8 paragraphs done.  Peer review set for October 28, with hard copy due on Monday, October 28.  Next up?  Directions.  We will chat about that assignment on Friday.

Posted on Thursday, October 17, 2019 at 07:49AM by Registered CommenterMarybeth Shea | CommentsPost a Comment

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>