Today, critique, which is a cousin of counter argument
Here is important reading about publication ethics:
- Paying by researchers to make open access (Opinion)
- Science news article on PubMed catching fakery
- Nature just overtook PlosOne (news feature)
- Retraction Watch (one of the first -- and best!)
- 11 tips on fraudulent journal protection at PlosOne bogs
- Peer review problems because of outsourcing (WaPo news piece)
Fake journal watch lists (not always kept up)
- Computer science focus (is this a bot)
- Librarian U Colorado system Jeffrey Beall's two lists aka Beall's Lists:
----
Critique in science articles: First, look at this Duke resource, including the two links at the end. You will be helped in more general tasks about your review. From the Duke page:
Note limitations of the study at the end of the essay:
o Do the data and conclusions contradict each other?
o Is there sufficient data to support the author’s generalizations?
o What questions remain unanswered?
o How could future studies be improved?
Marybeth Shea
Post a Comment
Reader Comments